If you are buying a Medicare Supplement in Hagerstown, you will hear from agents who all use the word advisor. Some can show you many companies. Others can show you only one. Knowing which is which changes the questions you should ask.
Two kinds of Medicare agents
A captive agent represents a single insurance company, or sells only that company's products. A broker, sometimes called an independent agent, is licensed with many companies and can compare them for you. Both are licensed, and both can be honest, helpful people. The difference is the starting menu. A captive agent starts with one company and works outward. A broker starts with you and works toward the companies that fit.
Ours is an independent agency, East Coast Health Advisors, based in Annapolis. Insurance companies pay us when a client enrolls, which means our help costs you nothing, and we are an agency rather than a public office or a charity. In your area we can show 36 products from 25 organizations, and our license in Maryland dates to 2011.
Why the difference matters for a Supplement
Because Supplement plans are standardized, a Plan G from one company covers the same benefits as a Plan G from another. That sounds like it makes the choice of agent irrelevant, but it does the opposite. When the benefits match, the price, the way the company raises rates, the household discounts and the quality of service are what separate one policy from another. Those are exactly the things a one company agent cannot compare.
Here in Washington County, that difference shows up in practical ways. A couple in their mid sixties might see monthly premiums for the same plan letter that are noticeably apart from one company to the next. They might also find that a lower first year premium is tied to a pricing method that climbs steadily with age. A broker can lay both paths side by side.
Questions to ask any Medicare agent
- How many companies can you show me? Ask for the number, not a promise of choice.
- What happens to the premium in ten years? Ask whether the company prices by issue age, attained age or community rating, and ask to see the path.
- How are you paid? Our answer is on the how brokers are paid page. Every honest agent should be glad to explain theirs.
- Who do I call after I enroll? A rate letter, a claim question or a new doctor can come up at any time.
- Will you tell me about options you do not sell? Medicare itself and other paths exist, and a good agent says so.
When a captive agent may be a fine choice
It is not our place to say a captive agent is wrong for you. If you already know and trust a specific company, have priced it against others, and like the agent who explains it, there is nothing unusual about staying. The point of a broker is the comparison, and a comparison is worth having even if you decide to stay where you are.
What to bring to a review
- Your Medicare card number (we will never ask you to read it in a public place)
- A list of your doctors and any prescriptions
- Your current coverage details, if you have any
- Your birthday and, if applicable, your partner's
When you are ready, book an appointment or call (410) 896-1212. You can also see the nearby care options on our Hagerstown health resources page.